Jeremy Browne should defect


A professor leaves Oxford to take up a job at Cambridge and raises the average intelligence of the staff at both institutions. This seems like a paradox but actually makes perfect sense. Anyone foolish enough to leave Oxford for Cambridge is no loss to the superior university. However, Cambridge would doubtless benefit from a staff member who spent time at Oxford.

I feel something similar about the prospect of Jeremy Browne leaving the Lib Dems for the Tories. A number of people seem to be considering the idea: Nick Boles has publicly floated the idea, Grant Shapps has approached Browne and many Lib Dems mutter about the prospect.

Brownes response to those Lib Dems is that they are sending a “very bad message” to voters. “If you believe that the country should live within its means, people should be encouraged to work [and] we should improve rigour in education, that doesn’t make you a Conservative but a reform-minded Liberal. We can’t get into a position where people misunderstood that.” His arguments with the straw man faction of the Liberal Democrats aside, Browne is clearly well outside the mainstream of the party. As Naomi Smith explains at the Huffington Post his views are at odds with the grassroots of the party. Furthermore, as James Graham notes his self-image as a true liberal is rather undermined by it being “an open secret that the main reason he was sacked from the home office was because he was so comfortable with the Tories’ anti-immigration and increasingly authoritarian policies.”

However, were Browne to join the Tories he would be one of their more moderate and progressive MPs. He would take a less deranged than average position on Europe and immigration, is a supporter of equal marriage and pro-choice.

So the impact of Jeremy Browne going from a Lib Dem to a Tory would be that both parties would become more liberal. So ironically if Jeremy Browne wants to be a true liberal, the best way for him to do it, would be to go from a more to a less liberal party.

8 thoughts on “Jeremy Browne should defect

  1. I would beg to disagree… we LibDems are a broad church and there is a certainly a place for neo-liberal MPs in the mix. Putting MPs into the right ministerial positions is an art-form. Nick Clegg took a very talented guy and put him in the wrong ministry at the Home Office… he should have been implanted somewhere in the finance and economy space.. the party has ignored the City at its peril and there is hay to be made there with a more defensive posture in defence of the UK’s financial interests.

    if we didn’t have a space there then we should have rejigged the Coalition arrangement to trade away something else to get him a suitable niche. Nick has rightly swung to the Left at this point to make space between us and the Tories and I feel sure that Jeremy Browne lies somewhere near the top of the list for inclusion at a future date in a most suitable place than the lower rungs of the Home Office.

  2. I’m afraid any argument based on an entirely subjective comparison of two great universities loses my patience entirely.

  3. I didn’t know that Oxford is a better university than Cambridge, so that allusion was lost on me. Reading Naomi Smith’s article, it was also news to me that shopping trolleys have a mind of their own. Who knew?

  4. Pingback: Top of the Blogs: The Lib Dem Golden Dozen #349
  5. It’s about time the LDs abandoned their suicidal support not just for Tory education policies but also for the disastrous changes in the NHS under the coalition, neither of which were party policy before the last election and have been falsely justified on financial grounds.

  6. Pingback: What Jeremy Browne’s retirement tells us about the Lib Dems | Matter Of Facts
  7. Pingback: Jeremy Browne to stand down as MP: what Lib Dem bloggers have made of his decision

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s